It is true that the law is simply a reflection of our own
prejudices.
In the 1996 movie “A
Time to Kill” Samuel L. Jackson stars as the father of a young girl that is
brutally raped by two white men in Canton, Mississippi. Enraged, and noting
that others were recently acquitted of the same crime in a nearby town, Jackson
obtains an assault rifle and kills the two men himself before they can be
tried. He enlists a local attorney to defend him, played by Matthew McConaughey,
and resists the advice of the local NAACP to hire their own high powered
attorneys for his defense.
In 1846 the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Roger B.
Taney wrote for the majority in the Dred Scott case that Blacks “Had no rights which the white man was bound
to respect”. There are few places where this was truer than Mississippi. It
was a foregone conclusion that Jackson’s character would die for killing two
white men in Mississippi. It did not matter what had happened to his daughter.
She had no rights that a white man was bound to respect, and neither did he. If
the Ku Klux Klan did not get him, the courts would.
One reason that Jackson’s character (Carl Lee Hailey) wanted
McConaughey’s character (Jake Brigance) to defend him was because they had
known each other for many years and although they considered themselves
friends, they were admittedly not close. However, Jake had a daughter that was
the same age as Carl’s.
As one would expect, the case created racial tension in the
community. There were demonstrations and riots. The governor called up the
National Guard to quell the riots. The KKK tried to bomb Jake’s home and
eventually burned it down. They killed his secretary’s husband and attacked his
assistant, (Sandra Bullock) tying her to a tree and leaving her to die (she was
rescued).
The prosecutor, played by Kevin Spacey, demanded the death
penalty and seemed destined to get it from an all-white jury until Jake’s
climactic closing statement before the jury. The courtroom was packed with
Black and white spectators. The streets outside the courthouse were filled as
well with people anxiously awaiting the outcome of the trial. The National
Guard was also there to maintain the fragile peace. After apologizing to the
jury for his own failings and asking the jury not to hold them against his
client, he told them he wanted to tell them a story. Then he said,
“Close your eyes, listen to me…listen to yourselves.
This is a story about a little girl, walking home from the grocery
store on a sunny afternoon. Suddenly a truck races up, two men jump out and
grab her. They drag her into a nearby field. They tie her up. They rip her
clothes from her body…They climb on. First one and then the other. Raping her.
Shattering everything precious and pure…with a vicious thrust…in a fog of
drunken breath and sweat.
When they’re done, after they’ve killed her tiny womb, murdered any
chance for her to bear children, to have life beyond her own, they use her for
target practice. So they start throwing full beer cans at her. They throw them
so hard, that it tears the flesh all the way to her bones.
Then they urinate on her.
Now comes the hanging. They have a rope. They tie a noose. Imagine the
noose coiling tight around her neck…and a sudden blinding jerk, she’s pulled
into the air, and her legs go kicking…they don’t find the ground. The hanging
branch…isn’t strong enough. It snaps, and she falls. Back to the earth. So they
pick her up, throw her in the back of the truck, drive out to Foggy Creek Bridge,
and pitch her over the edge. She drops some 30 feet, down to the creek bottom
below.
Can you see her?
Her raped, beaten, broken body…soaked in their urine.
Soaked in their semen.
Soaked in her blood.
Left to die.
Can you see her?
I want you to picture…that little girl…
Now…imagine…she’s white.”
That all-white jury in Mississippi acquitted Carl Lee
Hailey, a Black man of killing two white men.
Because in their hearts, they knew that if someone had
abused a white child in the same way that Carl Lee’s child had been abused, killing
the people that did it would be justifiable homicide.
An incredible amount of attention has been placed on recent
cases of young Black men being killed by police officers and pseudo law
enforcement individuals hiding behind ridiculous “stand your ground” laws. This
is not news. It has been the status quo in America for hundreds of years.
The third chapter and the third verse of the book of
Ecclesiastes says, “A time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down,
and a time to build up.”
“The law is simply a reflection of our own prejudices”.
Until the day arrives when America has overcome its racial
prejudices, the “time to kill” America’s Black men with impunity will not end.